Tough Talks on Tenant Discipline: MPs Clash Over Antisocial Behaviour Solutions
In a heated debate in Westminster Hall, MPs discussed the urgent need to address antisocial behaviour among social housing tenants, a concern that has been affecting countless communities across the UK. Reform UK MP Lee Anderson spearheaded the discussion, advocating for a ‘three strikes and you’re out’ policy aimed at deterring disruptive behaviour. He expressed frustration over the current eviction laws, arguing that merely evicting offenders does not account for viable housing solutions for them, stating, “I’m not bothered about where they go.”
Contrasting Anderson’s approach, Labour MP Steve Yemm criticized the three strikes policy as overly lenient, calling instead for a zero tolerance strategy to swiftly protect victims—many of whom endure years of hardship. Yemm suggested that victims of antisocial behaviour should promptly receive protection without the burden of accumulating extensive evidence of repeated offenses.
Further perspectives emerged with Labour MP Andrew Cooper urging for a more preventive approach, mentioning that tenants struggling with addiction should not be assigned to social housing without proper support. Liberal Democrat spokesperson Gideon Amos warned that while evictions might seem like a solution, they could merely displace problems from private dwellings to public spaces, intensifying overall antisocial behaviour.
Additionally, Shadow Housing Secretary Kevin Hollinrake emphasized that social housing should be treated as a privilege, indicating a broad consensus among MPs around tightening measures against antisocial behaviour.
Housing Minister Alex Norris acknowledged the shortcomings of current measures but highlighted ongoing efforts to enhance sanctions against repeat offenders, mentioning the introduction of the Respect Orders. He called for balancing tougher penalties with support for vulnerable tenants, particularly single mothers, recognizing housing stability as crucial for families. The debate reflects a strong push for reforms aimed at improving community safety while navigating the complexities of tenant support and rights.