Justice at Last: Inquiry into Emma Caldwell's Murder Begins Under Lord Scott

In a significant move toward justice, Scottish high court judge Lord Scott has been designated to lead the public inquiry into the murder of Emma Caldwell, whose tragic death occurred in 2005. Iain Packer, convicted last year of Emma’s murder, was identified as a suspect nearly two decades earlier but faced no charges until now, during which he was implicated in multiple sexual assaults against 22 women, including 11 rapes.

The inquiry was mandated amid public concern over the police investigation, after reports revealed that senior detectives had diverted focus away from Packer and instead pursued innocent Turkish men as suspects. The Caldwell family, seeking closure, initially advocated for an external chair for the inquiry but later expressed trust in Lord Scott’s appointment. Emma’s mother, Margaret Caldwell, expressed hope for progress, stating, “I’m happy with this decision – I’m hoping things will get going now. We’ve waited a long long time and there’s no closure as far as I’m concerned.”

Lord Scott, who has a distinguished background as a human rights lawyer, is expected to lead the inquiry with integrity and transparency, aiming to uncover the truth behind the police’s handling of the case. Justice Secretary Angela Constance emphasized the inquiry’s purpose, which is to deliver answers to victims and ensure future incidents are handled correctly. With strong public interest and a commitment to thoroughness, Lord Scott is poised to navigate this complex case and advocate for justice for Emma and the other victims involved.